Activity

From 18 Feb 2015 to 19 Mar 2015

19 Mar 2015

01:36 pm Task #2215: MIWP-8 (E-1) Integrate Theme specific metadata

What hasn't been documented by now in the Excel table is the different view on data quality depending on the seve...

Peter Kochmann
11:31 am Task #2215: MIWP-8 (E-1) Integrate Theme specific metadata

By now I didn't think of having the Excel table itself in the TG document. My intention was to have an overview o...

Peter Kochmann
09:56 am Task #2215: MIWP-8 (E-1) Integrate Theme specific metadata

I made two example pdf's of the current content of excel-file and attached them to wiki
https://ies-sv...

Michael Östling
12:21 pm Document: Working document TG Metadata not yet for review

There still chapters missing for this document.
Document is not published for review

Michael Östling
12:21 pm TG_MD_IR_and_ISO_MIWP8_draft.doc

Working document TG Metadata

Michael Östling

18 Mar 2015

04:26 pm Task #2219: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS

Maybe I've drawn the wrong conclusions with this issue. So I'm afraid I have to recall my statement #6.

I ...

Peter Kochmann
04:25 pm Task #2212: MIWP-8 (A) Conditions applying to access and use

Maybe I've drawn the wrong conclusions with this issue. So I'm afraid I have to recall my statement #17.

I...

Peter Kochmann
03:19 pm Task #2212: MIWP-8 (A) Conditions applying to access and use

I don't see the real difference here Peter, could you elaborate.
The example in 4.6.4  (TG SDS V 3.1) shows...

Michael Östling
11:55 am Task #2306: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Specification

I see the scope for the Specification is actually   Additional Requirements on Metadata Set Out in Regulation (E...

Michael Östling
11:15 am Task #2309: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Point of contact

I think I have to revert my opinion.

When reading the COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 1312/2014

I see now only

...

Michael Östling

17 Mar 2015

05:59 pm Bug #2324: Interoperability Metadata - Encoding

If the use of encoding should be as it is described in IR

3. Encoding: Description of the computer language constr...

Michael Östling

16 Mar 2015

01:27 pm Task #2212: MIWP-8 (A) Conditions applying to access and use

When I looked up the issue of "Restrictions related to the access and use" in SDS I got aware of the follow...

Peter Kochmann
01:21 pm Task #2219: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS

I just got aware that there is no ticket for the issue of "Restrictions related to the access and use" in S...

Peter Kochmann

12 Mar 2015

04:30 pm Task #2310: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Contains operation

if there are no other suggestions, i propose only to describe the mandatory elements in the TG

Ine de Visser
03:55 pm Task #2214: MIWP-8 (D) Integrate metadata for interoperability into the Metadata TG.

I also agree to that solution

Ine de Visser

11 Mar 2015

07:08 pm Task #2214: MIWP-8 (D) Integrate metadata for interoperability into the Metadata TG.

I'm agree with not considering at all the specification element and considering only the mandatory elements ...

Antonio Rotundo
03:48 pm Task #2214: MIWP-8 (D) Integrate metadata for interoperability into the Metadata TG.

Any ideas how to deal with the specification element in MD_Format finally? I skipped it in the latest Excel sheet due...

Peter Kochmann
04:39 pm Task #2309: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Point of contact

I would not agree to having the distribution structure of ISO for that.

It's clearly named to take the respons...

Peter Kochmann
04:18 pm Task #2306: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Specification

For my understanding there is no alternative than using DQ_ConformanceResult for SDS specification.

The descriptio...

Peter Kochmann
03:49 pm Bug #2324: Interoperability Metadata - Encoding

Any ideas how to deal with the specification element in MD_Format finally? I skipped it in the latest Excel sheet due...

Peter Kochmann

10 Mar 2015

11:48 am Task #2214: MIWP-8 (D) Integrate metadata for interoperability into the Metadata TG.

As discussed before I finished the Excel sheet and considered the mandatory and conditional elements of ISO 19115 onl...

Peter Kochmann
11:39 am Task #2215: MIWP-8 (E-1) Integrate Theme specific metadata

As announced above I finished the Excel sheet and considered the mandatory and conditional elements of ISO 19115 only...

Peter Kochmann
11:01 am Task #2215: MIWP-8 (E-1) Integrate Theme specific metadata

Peter Kochmann schrieb:

Otherwise I propose to consider the mandatory and optional ones only and of course the one...

Peter Kochmann

08 Mar 2015

05:27 pm Task #2304: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Category

This is just for the discussion. The IR demands us to use a specific element for Category.
If not that have been so ...

Michael Östling

05 Mar 2015

02:06 pm Task #2221: MIWP-8 (M) Coupled resource

I've read carefully the mail from Michel and I thought about the issue again. My proposal from post#41 covers the...

Pawel Soczewski
01:03 pm Task #2215: MIWP-8 (E-1) Integrate Theme specific metadata

The revised table considering lineage for the descriptive results of data quality elements is still in progress. Sorr...

Peter Kochmann
11:41 am Task #2212: MIWP-8 (A) Conditions applying to access and use

I think consensus is unreachable on this topic : we have understood that fields under different way and it is too lat...

Marc Leobet
10:51 am Task #2212: MIWP-8 (A) Conditions applying to access and use

As far as I understood ISO 19115, there's no difference in expressing useLimitation via MD_Constraints (alone) or...

Peter Kochmann
10:05 am Task #2212: MIWP-8 (A) Conditions applying to access and use

I strongly support the Ine's proposal: "A codelist with language neutral codes should be helpfull to ha...

Marc Leobet
11:02 am Task #2305: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Resource locator

In the current TG MD a resource locator coulb be "- a link to a web with further instructions" It's not...

Ine de Visser
10:56 am Task #2309: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Point of contact

Yes the Custodian vs Distributor is relevant in UK too - we explicitly draw a disticntion as not all data producers h...

James Reid
08:26 am Task #2309: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Point of contact

I agree on that using the resourcecontact with role custodian is the simplest solution, maybe also most correct.
I w...

Michael Östling
10:03 am Task #2219: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS

@ Geraldine,

What do you think is the best solution possible with the fact that the commision regulation on SDS is...

Ine de Visser
09:32 am Task #2306: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Specification

I can't follow your comment, please explain what you mean with

"The suggested implementation for SDS Spec...

Ine de Visser

04 Mar 2015

09:09 pm Task #2306: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Specification

I don't feel fully comfortable with this implementation. 
Maybe I need to get some clarifications on t...

Michael Östling
07:59 pm Task #2304: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Category

I would interpret the distinction between a Spatial Data service and Network services as Ine describes above.

...

Michael Östling
06:37 pm Task #2219: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS

I was out for months (maternity leave), so this comment is not on time. But I really think it is a shame that it is f...

Geraldine Nolf
04:10 pm Task #2221: MIWP-8 (M) Coupled resource

For your information:

In the branch of our GeoNetwork node (Flanders - Belgium) we use too both uuidref (to the re...

Geraldine Nolf
03:30 pm Task #2212: MIWP-8 (A) Conditions applying to access and use

we use MD_Constraints/gmd:useLimitation to fullfil 2.9.2. A codelist with language neutral codes should be helpfull&n...

Ine de Visser

03 Mar 2015

04:14 pm Task #2304: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Category

Sorry it takes my more time to understand where you refer to;

In the metadata regulation there are no network serv...

Ine de Visser
03:29 pm Task #2304: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Category

In metadata regulation (1205/2008) as I see it, spatial data service type is a wider classification.

There is not ...

Age Sild
02:51 pm Task #2304: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Category

In my opinion, if a service is not a INSPIRE network service it's also not a view service because thats an INSPIR...

Ine de Visser

02 Mar 2015

01:38 pm Task #2304: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Category

OK. We can distinguish INSPIRE Network services and Spatial Data Services (SDS). Regulation 1312/2014 is about Spatia...

Age Sild

25 Feb 2015

05:22 pm Task #2310: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Contains operation

In our metadata profile we considered the mandatory elements operationName, DCP and connectPoint only. We never misse...

Peter Kochmann
04:55 pm Task #2308: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Quality of service

I think Ine's proposal to take DataQuality elements is absolutely right, because they are already used (abused?) ...

Peter Kochmann
11:59 am Task #2306: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Specification

My state of knowledge is as follows:

For INSPIRE spatial dataset and series the conformity statement aims at least...

Peter Kochmann
11:54 am Bug #2322: Interoperability Metadata - CRS

Some input on this.

In the Spatial data Services  TG version 3.1

They mention on page 26 in...

Michael Östling
11:40 am Task #2304: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Category

I wasn't aware that the draft of TG SDS contains details on metadata. I assumed to find functional issues only.
...

Peter Kochmann
11:34 am Task #2305: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Resource locator

I did not follow the discussion about the meaning of accessPoint completely, I want to give a comment on the proposed...

Peter Kochmann

24 Feb 2015

04:16 pm Task #2304: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Category

Am I right to assume that all metadata describing SDS (invocable, interoperable, harmonised) have to fulfil IR Metada...

Peter Kochmann

19 Feb 2015

05:25 pm Task #2304: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Category

Thanks Martin to highlight this point. I passed too fast over the Ine's  comment #7. 

It would be be...

Marc Leobet
02:16 pm Task #2308: MIWP-8 (J) Metadata for SDS Quality of service

I must say, that I don't have new ideas, but

I would prefer choosing the way, that makes less trouble for user...

Age Sild
 

Also available in: Atom