Activity

From 23 Feb 2016 to 23 Mar 2016

23 Mar 2016

07:30 pm Enquiry #2728: Localised versions of ISO code lists

Hi Angelo, I'm open for concrete suggestions regarding the codeList attribute value. I don't have a stake her...

Ilkka Rinne
07:13 pm Enquiry #2728: Localised versions of ISO code lists

Ilkka Rinne wrote:

That may be, but the codeList attribute is mandatory by the XML Schema rules. So something must...

Angelo Quaglia
06:26 pm Enquiry #2728: Localised versions of ISO code lists

Angelo Quaglia wrote:

The validation of the codeList attribute value is unnecessary and actually to be avoided whe...

Ilkka Rinne
05:23 pm Enquiry #2728: Localised versions of ISO code lists

The validation of the codeList attribute value is unnecessary and actually to be avoided when using standard ISO with...

Angelo Quaglia
09:19 am Enquiry #2728: Localised versions of ISO code lists

Personally I would like to mandate linking to a non-localized version of the codelists. Localized code lists make val...

Ilkka Rinne
08:44 am Enquiry #2728 (New): Localised versions of ISO code lists

By: Marie Lambois

Chapter/section: 2.2.3

Paragraph/table: Note 11

Type: te

Comment: I...

Ilkka Rinne
04:46 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Dear Marc,

Indeed, standard specifications are the results of consensus.

Once a standard specification is adopt...

Angelo Quaglia
04:32 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Dear colleagues,

 

Unfortunately I have few times now to read all your production. I just would like to su...

Marc Leobet
09:45 am Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Please find an updated version of the comment resolution spreadsheet attached.

Ilkka Rinne
01:52 pm Enquiry #2735: ISO 19157 implied when discussing Lineage?

Does anybody know why my comments on this appear as having edited the whole page?

Peter Kochmann
11:51 am Enquiry #2735: ISO 19157 implied when discussing Lineage?

Considerung ISO 19157 will work only when considering new ISO 19115-1 as well, because both belong together. Today we...

Peter Kochmann
09:05 am Enquiry #2735 (New): ISO 19157 implied when discussing Lineage?

By: James Reid

Chapter/section: 3.4.1

Paragraph/table: TG Recommendation 1.6, Page 51

Type: ed/te

Comment...

Ilkka Rinne
11:50 am Enquiry #2737: Require the use of id attribute for MD_DataIdentification elements

As I mentioned in my comment, the id attribute and fragment identifier are not needed if the URL returns a MD_DataIde...

Angelo Quaglia
11:48 am Enquiry #2737: Require the use of id attribute for MD_DataIdentification elements

As discussed while the meeting last week the alternative containing the URI only will not demand an explicit id attri...

Peter Kochmann
09:12 am Enquiry #2737 (New): Require the use of id attribute for MD_DataIdentification elements

By: Angelo Quaglia

Chapter/section: 5.2.4

Paragraph/table: TG Req.3.6 and side note

Type: te

Comment: &qu...

Ilkka Rinne
09:24 am Enquiry #2736: Spatial resolution for services to be given in abstract

Unfortunately it does not help much even if this was solved in ISO 19115:2014, because the OGC srv schema mandated by...

Ilkka Rinne
09:09 am Enquiry #2736 (New): Spatial resolution for services to be given in abstract

By: Ine de Visser, Angelo Quaglia

Chapter/section: 5.2.1

Paragraph/table: TG Req.3.3

Type: te

Comments:
...

Ilkka Rinne
09:21 am Enquiry #2731: Require texts "no conditions apply" and "conditions unknown" in metadata

To be discussed in the group. The code list values are already required, do the free text values also need to be ther...

Ilkka Rinne
08:54 am Enquiry #2731 (New): Require texts "no conditions apply" and "conditions unknown" in metadata

By: Angelo Quaglia

Chapter/section:2.3.6

Paragraph/table: TG Req.A.18

Type: te

Comment: "The law req...

Ilkka Rinne
09:19 am Enquiry #2727: Schema locations for ISO 19139

I could not find the XML Schema files under http://standards.iso.org/iso/19139/

 

Ilkka Rinne
08:42 am Enquiry #2727 (New): Schema locations for ISO 19139

By: Marie Lambois

Chapter/section: 2.1

Paragraph/table: Note 6

Type: te

Comment: The ...

Ilkka Rinne
09:17 am Enquiry #2726: Require official schemaLocation URLs for gmd and srv

This is not about the validation really, but about whether it’s allowed for the schemaLocation to point to an U...

Ilkka Rinne
08:40 am Enquiry #2726 (New): Require official schemaLocation URLs for gmd and srv

By: Ine de Visser

Chapter/section: 2.1

Paragraph/table: Footnote 5,6,7,8

Type:

Comment:&nb...

Ilkka Rinne
09:02 am Enquiry #2734 (New): Use Lineage in addition to ISO quality elements

By: Ine de Visser

Chapter/section: 3.4.1

Paragraph/table: TG Recommendation 1.6

Type: te

Comment: "I...

Ilkka Rinne
09:00 am Enquiry #2733 (New): Detection of linkage type in transferOptions

By: Lenka Rejentova

Chapter/section: 3.3.1

Paragraph/table:

Type: te

Comment: There is no direct mec...

Ilkka Rinne
08:58 am Enquiry #2732 (New): gmx:Anchor for keywords, INSPIRE registry vs. GEMET

By: Lenka Rejentova

Chapter/section: 3.2.2.

Paragraph/table:

Type: ge

Comment: GEMET or INSPIRE registry...

Ilkka Rinne
08:50 am Enquiry #2730 (New): Legally mandated information on fees in conditions applying to access and use

By: Angelo Quaglia

Chapter/section: 2.3.6

Paragraph/table: TG Recommendation A.9

Type:

Com...

Ilkka Rinne
08:47 am Enquiry #2729 (New): Limitation of public access based on point (b) of Article 13(1)

By: Ine de Visser

Chapter/section: 2.3.5

Paragraph/table: TG Requirement A.16

Type: te

Com...

Ilkka Rinne
08:36 am Enquiry #2725 (New): Allow extending (profiling) of gmd and srv schemas

Spreadheet row: 15

By: Marie Lambois

Chapter/section: 2.1

Paragraph/table: First paragraphs

Typ...

Ilkka Rinne
08:35 am Document: TG v.2.0 RC1

Release candidate 1 created by Ilkka Rinne and submitted to MIWP-8 internal review on 29th February 2016.

Ilkka Rinne
08:35 am TG_MD_20_RC1_2016-02-29.pdf

Ilkka Rinne

16 Mar 2016

11:21 am Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

The URL used in the xlink:href attribute of each operatesOn element can be whatever one deems appropriate but:

...

Angelo Quaglia

15 Mar 2016

04:03 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Lines 175 up to 188 concerning coupledResource (5.2.4,  4.1.2.4 in edited draft rc2) show that the discussion is...

Peter Kochmann
01:33 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Antonio Rotundo wrote:

Two additional comments that I directly provide here below, even if after the deadline. It ...

Ilkka Rinne
01:27 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Ine de Visser wrote:

@Ilkka, You mentioned a meeting, wednesday on the comments. I am not aware of a meeting. is t...

Ilkka Rinne
01:07 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

@Ilkka,

You mentioned a meeting, wednesday on the comments. I am not aware of a meeting. is this a meeting for the...

Ine de Visser
12:15 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Two additional comments that I directly provide here below, even if after the deadline.

It is not clear why onl...

Antonio Rotundo
11:56 am Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Please find the combined comments for the RC1 version sent as comments to this issue, attached in an Excel spreadshee...

Ilkka Rinne
08:00 am Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Please find attached my comments, generaly to annex B.

Pawel Soczewski

14 Mar 2016

08:20 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Please find comments by Angelo Quaglia (JRC) attached.

Michael Lutz
05:49 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Here is an input from my colleague who is our metadata expert:

"I agree with previous comments from (270...

Christina Wasström
03:33 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Please see the comments made on the TG for metadat.

I have found the structure easier to navigate.

Alex Ramage
...

Alex Ramage
03:27 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Geraldine Nolf schreef:

Hello, I couldn't follow the working group anymore by a lack of time since the INSPIRE...

Geraldine Nolf
02:45 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Hello,

I couldn't follow the working group anymore by a lack of time since the INSPIRE-conference 2015. Now I ...

Geraldine Nolf
11:25 am Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Please find attached our comments. Already mentioned remarks by colleagues are marked in grey.

Christine Brendle
02:04 am Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Please find attached my comments. I previously checked what provided by the other WG members in order to avoid redund...

Antonio Rotundo

13 Mar 2016

07:46 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Good evening all,

Sorry for not being able to provide your with the promised comments synthesis yet. My overall im...

Ilkka Rinne

10 Mar 2016

06:10 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

In the attachment my comments on chapter 2, 3 and 5

Ine de Visser

08 Mar 2016

11:23 am Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Please find attached some joint editorial and general comments on the technical guidelines documents from IGN Spain, ...

Javier Nogueras Iso
09:08 am Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Thanks for all the comments provided. I will create a synthesis of them today and post it in this issue

Ilkka Rinne
07:30 am Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

I think that new strukture is good and clear.

I'd add only examples of XML encoding in sections 2 - 8 for all ...

Pawel Soczewski

07 Mar 2016

03:32 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

I'm already working on feedback on Annex B! It will be uploaded together with feedback on CC1 and CC3 the next da...

Peter Kochmann
03:24 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Generally speaking the structure seems clear. I would agree with Peter suggestion to group the CC by their subject (d...

Marie Lambois
02:41 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

I think the structure of the document is good and clear with soma comments mentioned above.

I also attach a few te...

Lenka Rejentova

05 Mar 2016

06:40 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

I think too that in general the new structure is clear and that it can work.

My only proposals are the following:
...

Antonio Rotundo

04 Mar 2016

02:43 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

I think its a clear structure!

Avoiding duplicates and also avoiding specific text for the  different resourc...

Ine de Visser
10:47 am Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

It takes some time to get used to this new structure but I think it will work!

Having this chapter 2 with general ...

Peter Kochmann
10:14 am Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Hi all,

Just a reminder for providing the comments & feedback for the new TG MD document structure by next Mon...

Ilkka Rinne
10:01 am Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Thanks Alex!

Alex Ramage wrote:

One very quick comment on Page 7 the document should read Changes from Version ...

Ilkka Rinne

29 Feb 2016

05:16 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

One very quick comment on Page 7 the document should read Changes from Version 1.3 to 2.0 and not Changes from Versio...

Alex Ramage
04:54 pm Consultation #2708: Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes 1 and 3 ...

Dear MIWP-8 experts and MIG-T representatives,

as announced last week, please provide feedback on

the struct...

Michael Lutz
04:49 pm Consultation #2708 (Closed): Feedback on draft Metadata TG v2.0 - structure & conformance classes...

Please find attached a draft (release candidate 1) for the Metadata TG version 2.0.

This draft includes the comple...

Michael Lutz
 

Also available in: Atom