MIWP-8 (E-1) Integrate Theme specific metadata

This section has now been locked for editing and a draft version have been moved into the draft document.
See page:
https://ies-svn.jrc.ec.europa.eu/projects/metadata/wiki/DraftVersionsMIWP-8
Further discussions and comments should be done on the draft

Ticket: https://ies-svn.jrc.ec.europa.eu/issues/2215

Right now there are number of optional metadata elements spread out over a number of INSPIRE Data Specifications.
The metadata TG will be updated to include those “optional” metadata elements within and updated TG because some data providers are producing theme specific data services already.
This will allow those organizations that wish to use the optional elements to have appropriate 19115 elements in the metadata for this purpose.

 

Members

Peter Kochmann
Lucie Kondrova
Ine de Visser
Christine Gassner
Manfred Mittlboeck
Pierluigi Cara  (Leader)
Michael Östling

 

 

Issue analysis

What problems causes current solution ?

Most of the mentioned metadata elements do not have a precise mapping to ISO 19115-elements. In some cases a mapping can be derived from the given examples. A problem in future could be a different view on these theme specific elements and thereby a different mapping.

 

What can be a solution on current problem ?

We need to find an exact mapping of the given metadata "information" to existing ISO 19115-elements especially in case that the given examples do not apply precise metadata elements. One possible way could be to make use of existing draft mapping tables and to transform these information into Technical Guidance "style".

Comment from Peter Kochmann (DE): Last year I built up a German draft mapping table assuming precise ISO 19115-elements (see attached file). Some of them do not match an element by now but a whole structure.

Comment from Manfred Mittlboeck (AT) [15-02-05]: We are working on a mapping table referencing the Austrian metadata profile (profil.AT) with the INSPIRE requirements also referring ISO 19115 and ISO 1915. The referencing is based on INSPIRE documents by November 2014 on the INSPIRE website also including the metadata cardinalities. Right now we compare this list with Peter Kochmanns list published here and are working on the consolidation.

 

How does it relate to IR ?

To be verified: IR metadata contains tables of metadata elements for data and services giving a multiplicity as well. Only mandatory and optional elements are mentioned. In case of data regarding IR interoperability the additional metadata elements could be considered in IR metadata too though they are flagged as optional.

 

How will the solution affect existing tools ?

 

How will the solution affect existing metadata ?

 

What other issues in MIWG-8 is related to this change ?

 

What other groups within MIG-related workgroups could be linked to this issue ?

 

2013-06-17_themenspezifische_Metadaten_INSPIRE.xls (51 KB) Peter Kochmann, 01 Dec 2014 02:27 pm

2013-06-17_themespecic_metadata_INSPIRE.xlsx (26 KB) Peter Kochmann, 03 Dec 2014 02:38 pm

2014-12-03_themespecific_metadata_INSPIRE.xlsx (22.7 KB) Peter Kochmann, 04 Dec 2014 08:52 am

2014-12-17_metadata_theme_specific_INSPIRE_first_example.xlsx - first example to be discussed - please look at the ticket for further information (18.2 KB) Peter Kochmann, 17 Dec 2014 11:05 am

2015-01-07_metadata_theme_specific_INSPIRE.xlsx - please look at the ticket for further information (41.1 KB) Peter Kochmann, 07 Jan 2015 05:17 pm

2015-01-22_metadata_theme_specific_INSPIRE_19115.xlsx - no big progress at all; please look at the ticket for further information (41.1 KB) Peter Kochmann, 29 Jan 2015 01:45 pm

themespecific_austrian_metadata_INSPIRE_cross_reference_v6_150130.xlsx - List on cross referencing the Austrian metadata standard with INSPIRE metadata requirements. As basis for the data specification metadata (we used the documents available on the INSPIRE website by November 2014. There is also linkage with ISO 19157 (62.2 KB) Manfred Mittlboeck, 05 Feb 2015 01:07 pm

2015-01-22_metadata_theme_specific_INSPIRE_19115-IdV.xlsx - Also my nput based on the duth metadata profile (42.2 KB) Ine de Visser, 05 Feb 2015 01:48 pm

2015-03-09_metadata_theme_specific_INSPIRE_19115.xlsx - using lineage for descriptive results in data quality; please look at the ticket for further information (33.8 KB) Peter Kochmann, 10 Mar 2015 11:40 am

2015-03-09_metadata_theme_specific_INSPIRE_19115.pdf - Would this be a way to display it in TG?: Summary table with Element definitions - maybe a way to display this content by making two separate views (83.6 KB) Michael Östling, 19 Mar 2015 09:45 am

2015-03-09_metadata_theme_specific_INSPIRE_19115_2.pdf - Would this be a way to display it in TG?: Summary table with list of Annexes - maybe a way to display this content by making two separate views (56.8 KB) Michael Östling, 19 Mar 2015 09:45 am

2015-03-31_metadata_theme_specific_INSPIRE_19115.xlsx - I added a mapping for the data quality focus and the concerned annex themes. And the XPaths are now included. (46 KB) Peter Kochmann, 31 Mar 2015 03:31 pm